Skip to content

Revisiting a Classic: Mac and Cheese

15.August 2011

It’s been a Comfort Food kind of week around Darby O’Shea HQ and so we’re revisiting a classic post from almost two years ago.  I’m happy to report that my mom, who inspired this post, has fully recovered from the heart attack that threw us all for such a loop and is doing very, very well these days.  This gives me hope that, as she always says, “this too shall pass.”  

I’m also re-posting this to enter in the America’s Test Kitchen “Dish it Your Way” challenge.  (You should enter too!)


Sometimes something terrible happens and, even when everything resolves itself miraculously well, you can see cracks forming in an edifice you had previously held to be unshakable, unchangeable, permanent. Whether you have any warning or not, this kind of occurrence has the power to shake even the most staunchly positive Pollyanna of us all to the core.

When these things happen, as they have of late, what do I do? First, I keep a stiff upper lip. Second, I have a private and generally very dramatic meltdown. Third, I pull it together and cleave to something comfortable, reliable, something that is always the same as it always was and something that will, for all eternity, remain comforting, reliable, warm.

Obviously, I’m a stress eater. After all, what besides food (provided you have a reliable ingredients and a good relationship with the particular stove and oven at your disposal) is so reliable and comforting? When under normal stress, things like cake, Cheez-its, chocolate, and cream cheese do me just fine. On the other hand, when things get really out of hand, I need something a little more serious to prop me up. Most recently I turned to Mac and Cheese.

If you’re running off to the cupboard to zap some Easy Mac, HALT. Go no further! A far superior Mac and Cheese awaits you. And if, like me, you find yourself soothed by procedure, routine, and production, then this, friends, is the Mac and Cheese for you. There is no microwave involved. No vaguely-cheesy orange powder. No tablespoon of butter and half cup of milk. This is a much more involved Mac and Cheese but let me assure you: as with so many things, what you get out of this Mac and Cheese is directly proportional to what you put into it. If you’re lucky, it may even give you back morethan you bargained for.

Luckily, my recipe-source (and inadvertent source of this month’s stress) had recovered fully enough to dictate this recipe and help cook it by the time I was up to needing some emotional sustenance. I can’t take credit for this recipe. As ever, all credit to my mom.

Reliable Comfort Food


  • 1 box macaroni noodles (I used Barilla Elbows)
  • 1 stick butter
  • 1/3 cup flour
  • 1 t dry mustard
  • nutmeg to taste (ca. 1/2 t)
  • 1/4 t salt
  • 1 quart milk
  • 1/2 lb White American Cheese
  • 1/2 lb Monterey Jack Cheese
  • 1/2 lb Cheddar Cheese (medium sharp)


  1. Pre-heat oven to about 400.
  2. Cook pasta in generously salted water for approximately 3/4 of the suggested time. Drain and set aside.
  3. Shred American, Monterey Jack, and Cheddar Cheeses on the largest holes on a box grater. Set aside
  4. Make a roux: Melt the stick of butter over medium heat. Add the flour and whisk until smooth. Add milk and cook over medium-low heat until sauce bubbles, thickens, and just begins to brown. Add dry mustard and nutmeg.
  5. Add cheese and stir until melted and smooth.
  6. Add pasta to cheese sauce and stir until well coated.
  7. Pour pasta and sauce into a (large) oven-safe dish- in my case this was a 9″x13″ stoneware baking dish AND a 9″x9″ brownie dish.
  8. Bake at 400 until it begins to brown on top. If you’re lucky, your oven will brown it more or less evenly. If you’re me, your oven will beautifully brown one side and leave the other more or less raw. It tastes fine either way.

We all ate this as a “side dish” to accompany a sesame-ginger marinated pork tenderloin, alongside some delicious lima beans, (see image above) but we all knew that the Mac was the main attraction. It’s okay to exercise a little denial when it comes to this dish. We all know that you just want to eat carbs saturated with cheesy fat. And sometimes there’s just nothing at all wrong with that.

In other news, look what my orchid has been doing! He’s (I’m firmly of the opinion that anything named after testicles should be called he, though perhaps orchids could be the drag queens of the plant world – hence my deep and abiding love of them) certainly been up to the task of brightening up the house the last couple weeks! I like how that last little bloom is cocking its head at the camera and being so coy to open up. What a tight little ball of joy.

5 Comments leave one →
  1. 21.September 2011 07:20

    Mmm, nothing beats homemade mac and cheese! I like mine with toasted bread crumbs on top!

    • Darby O'Shea permalink*
      3.October 2011 10:57

      Ooh, you’ve touched on a divisive issue there! To crumb or not to crumb! Obviously we’re of the no-crumb persuasion, but we try not to judge.

  2. 21.September 2011 15:20

    Mac and Cheese makes me smile everytime I eat it. Although, I traditionally make this dish the southern way, I just love your recipe. I can’t wait to try this out. Thanks for sharing

    • Darby O'Shea permalink*
      21.September 2011 16:45

      Need more info about the “southern way”! Send us a recipe?

  3. 28.September 2011 13:08

    Sounds wonderful and this is such a classic recipe.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: